Taxpayers are often under extreme stress when they receive a communication from the Income Tax Department. Furthermore, if the communication includes a Notice of Demand regarding payment of taxes that the taxpayer believes is incorrect or unjustified, the stress is further compounded. However, the notification issued to taxpayers via Notice of Demand under Section 156 of the Income Tax Act 1961, is frequently a source of considerable confusion and anxiety among taxpayers because it often consists of incorrect numbers or is a result of an obvious error made by the department. Therefore, many taxpayers seek an answer to the question: "What happens if the Income Tax Department issues a Notice of Demand under Section 156 to me that I think is wrong?" Is there a way for it to be fixed? Yes, the Notice can be corrected; however, the timeline, process to correct, and taxpayer obligations have great significance. This guide provides detailed information regarding what a Notice of Demand under Section 156 of the Income Tax Act is, examples of why a Demand issued is erroneous, recommended actions to take when receiving an incorrect Notice, and how the income tax department may rectify an erroneous Notice. This guide is written from the perspective of professional compliance providing insight on the proper response to an Income Tax Notice in India, while also ensuring that taxpayer rights are being upheld.
Understanding a Notice of Demand Under Section 156
The Income Tax Department issues a Notice of Demand under Section 156 when a taxpayer has an amount due consisting of tax, interest, penalty, fees, or any other amounts. This issuance will typically be a result of:
• Completion of an assessment or reassessment
• Processing a tax return per Section 143(1)
• Issuance of Rectification Orders (ROI) per Section 154
• Issuance of penalty orders or appellate orders (AO)
The notice will specify the amount that must be paid, and the taxpayer must make payment within 30 days of service of the notice or by the time specified within the notice.
Although legally enforceable, a Notice of Demand does not guarantee that the amount owed is accurate and that invalid Notices of Demand are relatively frequent due to the data-processing system and human error.
What Is a Wrong or Incorrect Notice of Demand?
A wrong notice of demand is one where the tax liability mentioned does not accurately reflect the taxpayer’s actual liability as per law. Such errors may occur even when the taxpayer has filed a correct return and paid due taxes on time.
A wrong demand can cause unnecessary financial pressure, block refunds, and create compliance complications if not addressed promptly through an appropriate Income Tax Notice Reply.
Common Reasons Why Wrong Demand Notices Are Issued
To successfully respond to an Income Tax Notice, you first need to understand what caused that Notice. There are several common reasons why notices are raised, including but not limited to:
1.Mismatched Tax Credit (Form 26AS / AIS / TIS)
If the tax deducted at source (TDS) or the tax collected at source (TCS) reported by your diductors does not match the information that exists in IRS records when your return was processed, the IRS system may generate a tax notice for excess tax liability.
2. Incorrect Adjustment During Processing Under Section 143(1)
As mentioned before, incorrect adjustments during return processing by CPC may result in unreasonable amounts being removed from taxable income. Therefore, it is possible for notices based on other than reasonable determinations of tax liability being generated by the IRS.
3. Non-Grants of Advance Tax or Self-Assessment Tax Credit
In many instances, taxpayers have paid some portion of their taxes, yet the total amount of the taxes owed is never fully taken into account when the IRS arrives at its final determination of tax liability following the completion of processing.
4. Mathematical Error or Mistakes
An example is if the IRS incorrectly calculated interest, made simple calculation mistakes, or entered incorrect amounts into the system will create a notice that is erroneous.
5. Lack of Incorporation of Appellate Decisions
If an appeal has already been approved or some other remedy or relief has been granted, but it has not yet been included in your file/record with the IRS or IRS will likely raise an incorrect demand.
6. Duplicate Demand
Sometimes, if you have made payment to either your tax professional or the IRS prior to receiving your tax notice, and due to technical glitches within the IRS system prior to this notice being issued, your name and address could have mistakenly appeared on both records.
What Should You Do When an Income Tax Notice Is Received with Wrong Demand?
Please do not ignore an income tax notice that you have received that looks incorrect. Timely and structured responses are critical.
1.Review the Notice in Detail
The following information should be confirmed:
• Assessment year
• Section under which the notice has arisen
• Total amount due
• Nature of the demand stated in the intimation or assessment order
All the statements made above must agree with the information in the income tax return you have submitted, tax payment challans, Form 26AS, the AIS you have received, and all previous orders you have received from your income tax department.
2. Identify the Specific Error
Establish whether the demand was incorrect because of:
• Tax paid that has not been recognized
• Deduction that was disallowed
• Interest that was calculated incorrectly
• Appeal order that was not recognized
Once you have established the error, you will be able to submit the correct Income Tax Notice Response.
3. Submit an Online Response to the Demand
Under the e-filing portal, all taxpayers can file responses regarding any outstanding demand:
• Demand is correct
• Demand is accurate only in part
• Do not agree with demand
If you believe that the demand has been incorrectly assessed, you must provide supporting documents and reasons for your disagreement.
Your online response to the demand is critical to the response to your Income Tax Notice, as the majority of corrections are conducted through digital filing.
Is Responding to a Wrong Notice Mandatory?
Even though it may be incorrect, not responding to or ignoring an Income Tax Notice is not an available choice. Non-response to an Income Tax Notice will lead to any of the following outcomes:
• Recovery actions
• Adjustment of refunds
• Accrued interest
• Initiation of penalties
• Potential legal issues
A timely response to an Income Tax Notice in India preserves your rights and helps to prevent unwarranted enforcement actions from occurring.
How Can a Taxpayer Respond to a Wrong Section 156 Demand?
1.Filing an Online Rectification Request via Section 154
Section 154 is the best solution to position yourself for a successful resolution if the issue is easily identifiable in the records.
Section 154 circumstances include:
1. An error in the tax credit.
2. An error in calculating tax.
3. An error in tax collection interest.
4. An error in document management.
To submit a Section 154 rectification, log into the Income Tax E-filing Portal:
In India, Section 154 Rectifications are the most frequently used solution to respond to income tax notices regarding unwarranted tax demands.
2. Submitting a Response to Demand on the Portal
To respond to the demand through the portal if there is an incorrect tax condition in full or part, do one of the following:
Select the response section “Response to Outstanding Demand”
Choose to respond as follows:
a) Demand is Correct.
b) Demand is etc.
c) Disagree with Demand.
You may also submit proof, such as a challenge, Form 26 AS, or acknowledgement of rectification.
3. Filing an Appeal with CIT(A)
If you receive a demand letter relating to an assessment or claim based on disagreement with a demand, file an appeal under Section 246A.
If Section 154 is not sufficient, filing an appeal with CIT(A) is the best option.
Can the Income Tax Department Rectify a Wrong Demand Later?
The IT Department has the right to correct their mistakes even after issuing demand notices.
Rectification Under 154 of Income Tax Act 1961
Under this section of the Income Tax Act 1961, Rectification is done for errors that are clear on the Record. Examples of such Errors are:
• Clerical Errors
• Mathematical Errors
• Adjustment of Tax Credit incorrectly
• Error in Data Matching
Taxpayers can also request Online Rectification to the I.T. Department or initiate rectification themselves. The time frame for the Rectification is generally Up To Four Years from the end of the Financial Year in which the Rectification Order is received.
Is Payment Mandatory Before Rectification?
There might be circumstances where if you disagree with the Demand, this does not mean that you need to make the payment immediately. However, if you disagree with the demand, it is best practice to:
• Provide a response within the set time limits
• Make sure to keep your documents showing evidence available
• If you think the demand is too large make an application for a stay of the demand.
If you do not respond the Tax Office may take collection action against you for payment even if the demand was issued in error.
What Type of Errors Can Be Rectified Under Section 154?
Rectifiable mistakes include:
Issues involving interpretation of law or debatable matters usually cannot be resolved under Section 154 and may require appeal proceedings.
What If the Demand Is Not Rectified?
If you receive an Income Tax notice that contains a wrong demand and do not respond properly to the notice, the following consequences may occur:
In addition, you can escalate the issue by:
Importance of Timely Income Tax Notice Response
To correct the Current Demand raised under Income Tax, it is vital to respond promptly, even when the time frame for the response is incorrect. Failure to respond on time will be interpreted as accepting the current demand which complicates the process for obtaining any future remedy for this action against the taxpayer.
Responding to the Income Tax Notice correctly and professionally will help the taxpayer to:
1. Protect against forcible collection
2. Allow for faster rectification of any errors
3. Create better records for compliance with tax laws
Impact of Not Responding to a Wrong Demand
Failure to respond to an incorrect demand can lead to:
This highlights the importance of timely Income Tax Notice Response.
Consequences of Ignoring a Wrong Demand Notice
Ignoring an income tax notice received can lead to serious consequences:
Prompt Income Tax Notice Response in India is therefore critical.
Drawbacks of Wrong Demand Notices
While it is possible to rectify wrong demands, they can still create practical problems, including:
Common Mistakes to Avoid While Responding
By avoiding the above mistakes, individuals can improve their experience when responding to Income Tax Notices.
Conclusion
Receiving an incorrect notice of demand under section 156 of the Income Tax Act may be a stressful experience for taxpayers, but there are many options available to taxpayers after receiving this type of notice. There are numerous protections available under Income Tax Act for taxpayers who received the wrong notice of demand, the main factors in correctly responding to a notice of demand under section 156 are taking action as soon as possible, keeping accurate records, and drafting a professionally written response to the Income Tax Notice. Whether you are a sole proprietor or another form of a business taxpayer, knowing what your rights are, as well as responding properly when you receive an income tax notice reflecting an incorrect demand can save you time and money, as well as help you avoid additional legal issues. If you respond in the correct manner and receive help from a qualified tax professional, an incorrect notice of demand can be handled in an expedient and lawfully.
FAQs
1. Is a Section 156 notice final and binding?
A Section 156 notice is legally enforceable, but it is not final if it contains errors. Taxpayers have the right to challenge it through a proper Income Tax Notice Reply.
2. Can I ignore a wrong demand notice?
No. Ignoring an incorrect notice can lead to recovery actions. A timely Income Tax Notice Response is essential, even if the demand is wrong.
3. How long does rectification take?
Rectification timelines vary. CPC-related errors may be resolved faster, while officer-level rectifications may take several weeks or months.
4. Will interest apply if the demand is later rectified?
If the demand is found incorrect and rectified, interest charged on such demand is usually reversed or nullified.
5. Can refunds be adjusted against a wrong demand?
Yes, refunds can be adjusted unless the demand is stayed or rectified. This is why timely Income Tax Notice Response in India is critical.
Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *