When a company or brand submits its trademark application, they may view it as a milestone event in their business’s journey. The company has created and conducted research into the availability of a unique name, logo, or brand to the best of their ability, and has also applied for registration of the trademark based on its particular classification of goods/services and the appropriate trademark class(es). However, if the applicant receives a "Notice of Trademark Objection" from the Trademark Office (where the application has been filed with) at any time after filing its application with it, many applicants assume that their application was not submitted correctly and/or that it will be rejected by the Trademark Office. The misconception arises from the misconception that it is rare to receive a trademark objection even if the trademark is unique and/or the applicant has appropriately filed in more than one class of trademarks. In fact, the issuance of trademark objections is actually more common than most applicants realize. In India, a large portion of trademark applications get objections during the examination phase of the process, which does not necessarily mean that your trademark will be deemed invalid or unregistrable; it just means that the Trademark Examiner requires further clarification, documentation, supporting arguments, or justification before allowing your trademark to move forward. This comprehensive guide explains why trademark objections are issued; how common they are; what it means when an applicant has filed a trademark application in multiple sections (classes) and how a properly prepared response to a trademark objection can assist the applicant by making the process to overcome an objection as smooth as possible. Whether you are a startup founder, business owner, or brand manager, understanding this process will help you respond confidently and protect your brand identity.
Understanding What a Trademark Objection Really Means
Trademark objections are preliminary examiners’ remarks raised by the Trade Mark Examiners under The Trade Marks Act-1999, to provide additional information after reviewing the trademark application at the first stage of examination.
• A trademark objection is not a trademark refusal
• A trademark objection does not mean that the brand is invalid
• A trademark objection requests the applicant for additional clarification, justification or correction to the trademark application by providing that requested information.
Furthermore, it is funded within the actual number of trademark applications filed in India to support the issuance of a trademark certificate of registration in India (i.e. to have been granted a trademark registration).
Is It Common to Receive a Trademark Objection in India?
In India, the fact that a considerable number of trademark applications are rejected is not unusual; in fact, it is due to the stricter examination requirements of the Trademark Registry as well as the rise in the number of trademarks submitted each year.
Even if the applicant does the following:
• Chooses a distinctive brand name;
• Does some preliminary research on the trademark;
• Files under the appropriate trademark classes;
• Applies for multiple sections or classes;
the applicant may still receive a trademark objection.
The trademark examiner evaluates the application based on the applicant's brand name's distinctiveness as well as a number of additional factors (including a legal understanding of the term, similarity when pronounced, what is descriptive about it and whether it meets the requirements associated with trademark law).
How Common Are Trademark Objections in India?
Trademark objections are very common in India. In fact, a significant percentage of trademark applications receive an objection at the examination stage. Even applications filed by established businesses, startups with unique names, or applicants using professional agents may face objections.
This happens because trademark examination is not just about name availability it involves legal interpretation, classification rules, descriptiveness, phonetic similarity, and statutory compliance.
So yes, receiving a Trademark Objection even for a unique name is completely normal.
Why Do Trademark Objections Occur Even for Unique Names?
Many people think that the uniqueness of their trademark will cause them to be approved. Unfortunately, trademark law considers more than simply being unique. Consequently, the following are some of the more common reasons that an applicant may encounter objections to their application:
1.Similarity to Existing Trademarks
If the applicant's trademark is not an exact match for an existing trademark, the examiner will then check for:
• Phonetic Similarity
• Visual Similarity
• Conceptual Similarity
If an applicant's trademark sounds the same as, or looks like, or represents a similar concept as an existing trademark that has already been registered or is currently pending, then it may be the subject to an objection under Section 11 of the Trade Marks Act 1999.
2. Descriptive / Generic Nature of Trademark
A trademark that describes the quality, nature, or purpose of the applicant's product(s)/service(s) will generally be the subject of an objection under Section 9. For example:
• "Express Delivery" for an express courier company
• "Underhill's Pure Milk" for a milk distributor
Therefore, applicants cannot monopolize the use of descriptive terms as a result of another applicant having previously registered such a trademark.
3. Incorrect Selection of Trademark Classes
When an applicant files for registration of a trademark in multiple classes, the applicant can encounter objections due to:
• Overlapping Descriptions of Goods/Services
• Broad and Vague Descriptions of Goods/Services
• An inconsistency between the applicant's business activity and the description of the class(es) in which the applicant is applying for registration.
Filing for registration of a trademark in two or more classes increases the level of scrutiny that will be placed on the application as the examiner will independently examine each class to determine whether or not the trademark should be registered.
4. Lack of Distinctiveness
A trademark must be capable of distinguishing your goods or services from others. Names that are:
may attract a Trademark Objection even if they are technically unique.
5. Improper Documentation or Formal Errors
Objections can also be procedural, such as:
These are avoidable but very common reasons for objections.
Types of Trademark Objections in India
A thorough understanding of the type(s) of objection(s) will allow for a much better response to the objection(s) raised.
1.Objection under Section 9 (Absolute Grounds)
Section 9 objections involve the inherent quality of the trademark; this can be due to the nature of the trademark itself, ie. Whether or not it is distinctive or descriptive.
2.Objection under Section 11 (Relative Grounds)
Section 11 objections arise when the registered trademark(s) are sufficiently similar to previously registered trademarks that they could confuse the public.
In any given trademark application, both Section 9 and Section 11 objections can be raised at the same time or just one section may be raised based on what the trademark examiner finds.
Step-by-Step Process After a Trademark Objection in India
Stage 1: Issuing Examination Report
An Examination Report will be generated by the Trademark Office providing information regarding the reasons for the refusal of an application for registration. Generally, the Examination Report will be issued within 30 days after the examination.
Stage 2: Deadline for Filing Response to Examination Report
You will have thirty (30) days from the date of receipt of the Examination Report to file a reply to the objection based on the Examination Report. If you fail to respond within this deadline your application will be considered abandoned.
Stage 3: Preparation of Reply to Examination Report
This is the most important stage of the process. Your reply to the objection must include:
• A separate response to each of the objections raised;
• The applicable legal basis for each of the objections; and
• Evidence (if any) supporting the legal basis for each of the objections; and
• Evidence of the distinctiveness and originality of your mark; and
• A response to any misconception created by the examiner.
A weak or generic reply significantly reduces the chances of acceptance.
Stage 4: Review of the Reply
The examiner will review your reply to the objection. If the examiner believes that you have successfully responded to the objections raised, the examiner will accept the application and it will be published in the Trademark Journal.
Step 5: Show Cause Hearing (If required)
If the examiner is not convinced, a hearing notice is issued. During the hearing, legal arguments are presented either physically or online.
Step 6: Acceptance or Refusal
Based on the reply and hearing, the trademark is either accepted for publication or refused. If accepted and unopposed, it proceeds to registration.
What Happens After You Receive a Trademark Objection?
Following a trademark examination report being issued, the trademark applicant is allotted thirty days to provide their trademark objection reply. If the thirty-day window closes without receiving a response, it is almost certain that the trademark application will be abandoned.
The trademark objection reply will need to:
1) Respond and address all stated objections raised against the application
2) Present strong legal arguments for why the trademark is registrable.
3) Include factual description of when the applicant began using the mark
4) If possible, the applicant should also submit relevant documentation to support one or all of the above.
A casual or poorly drafted reply significantly reduces the chances of acceptance.
Importance of a Strong Trademark Objection Reply
In effect, the trademark objection reply is not simply a response to the objections, but also serves as a defense of the applicant’s claim to protect this brand. An applicant's success in obtaining U.S. registration often hinges upon the quality of the trademark objection reply. A well-prepared objection reply must include:
1. Cite specific portions of the Trademark Act to support your claim.
2. Demonstrate the uniqueness and distinctiveness of the mark.
3. Prove the applicant has made a full and honest adoption and use of the mark.
4. Clarify the class and intent for use of the mark.
To properly prepare for this process, the applicant should consider hiring a professional trademark objection service.
Can You Handle a Trademark Objection on Your Own?
Technically, yes. Practically, it is risky.
Trademark law requires a lot of legal reasoning and has a lot of complex legal issues. An examiner will expect a legally reasoned response from your attorney, and not simply a generic explanation. Most self-prepared responses will fail to persuade the examiner for the following reasons:
· They lack any meaningful legal reasoning
· They incorrectly cite the law
· They contain emotional or informal language
· They do not respond to all objections
Using an Indian trademark objection service will help ensure that your response meets the expectations of the Registry.
What If the Examiner Is Not Satisfied with the Reply?
If the Trademark Examiner is not satisfied with the trademark objection response, they may schedule a hearing. In the hearing:
· Oral Argument
· Additional Documents
· The Examiner's Final Decision
Strongly recommend obtaining a lawyer's assistance at this point in the process.
Risks of Ignoring or Delaying a Trademark Objection
The following negative consequences could occur if a response to a trademark objection is not filed within the established timeframe:
1. The abandoned application.
2. The loss of any filing fee(s) paid to the government.
3. The resubmission of the trademark application.
4. The loss of priority date.
This means it is critical to act quickly and professionally.
Impact of a Trademark Objection on Your Business
Although receiving an objection does not halt your ability to continue operating your marketplace, it does impose certain obligations requiring your attention.
1.Market Uncertainty
Until the objection has been resolved, companies remain under scrutiny with regard to their use of the brand, creating uncertainty for potential investors, partners and/or licensees.
2.Registration Delays
Objections extend the registration timeline. For example; a trademark that may have been registered within a few months may take considerably longer if the objections are handled incorrectly.
3.Increased Compliance Responsibilities
Companies must respond to a trademark objection within the prescribed timeframe or the application may be deemed abandoned.
4.Brand Expansion Risks
If you intend to expand your brand, franchise your business or license for distribution, then pending unresolved objections may pose a hindrance to these goals.
Consequences of Ignoring a Trademark Objection
When you neglect or mismanage a trademark objection, there are potential negative outcomes including:
• Abandoning your application
• Losing priority based on the date of filing
• Re-filing your trademark completely from the beginning
• Increasing your costs and legal work
• Providing an opportunity for others to infringe on your trademark.
If your trademark application has been abandoned, you may find it very challenging if not impossible to reinstate it; this is why it is wise to seek help from a professional service that handles trademark objections.
Key Mistakes to Avoid When Responding to a Trademark Objection
• Ignoring an objection or not responding on time.
• Reusing generic application form templates via copy and paste.
• Not addressing all the points in an objection.
• Utilizing non-legal arguments or making emotional arguments.
• Responding past the deadline for the objection.
Each of these can result in the objection being denied or abandoned.
Common Myths About Trademark Objections
Myth 1: If you receive an objection, your application is going to be rejected.
Reality: Many applications get approved after the applicant provides the required information in their response to the objection.
Myth 2: Unique names will never be objected to.
Reality: The uniqueness of a name is not a guarantee of approval.
Myth 3: By filing your application online, you can be assured that it will be approved.
Reality: Filing an application is just the first step; the application must be examined by the Trademark Office to determine whether the registration will be granted.
Myth 4: You can respond to an objection yourself and your application will be approved.
Reality: If the response is poorly drafted, the risk of denial of the application will increase.
How Long Does It Take to Resolve a Trademark Objection?
The timeline varies depending on:
On average, resolution can take anywhere from a few months to over a year. However, a strong reply often speeds up the process.
Conclusion
Receiving an Objection to a Trademark Application is not an indication of failure; it is a common part of the Trademark Registration Process in India. A Trademark may be Unique or that the Trademark Application will have been filed properly in several classes or on multiple occasions will not mean that it will not get objected to by the Trademark Registry for other Legal Reasons, including the Legal Interpretation of a Trademark, Similarity Standards, and Examination Procedures. What ultimately makes or breaks your chances of getting your Trademark Registered is how well you respond to the Objection to the Trademark by providing a truly well-articulated response and how strategically you navigate the Examination Procedures in response to the Objection. Using Professional Trademark Objection Services, especially using Reliable Trademark Objection Services in India, will give you the ability to Protect Your Brand Effectively from Objections through a Strong Response and will give you the Confidence to Proceed to Obtain Long-Term Trademark Protection for Your Brand.
(FAQ)
1. Is receiving a Trademark Objection a bad sign?
No. A Trademark Objection is a normal part of the trademark registration process and does not mean rejection.
2. Can a unique name still face a trademark objection?
Yes. Even unique names can face objections due to similarity, descriptiveness, or classification issues.
3. How much time do I get to reply to a trademark objection?
You get 30 days from the date of issuance of the examination report to submit a trademark objection reply.
4. What happens if I don’t reply to the objection?
Failure to reply within the deadline can result in abandonment of the trademark application.
5. Is professional help necessary for trademark objection services?
While not mandatory, professional trademark objection services significantly improve the chances of acceptance
Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *